Some readers have emailed me about whether daytime naps are or aren’t a good thing. After all, isn’t the Latin American concept of the “siesta” considered a way of life in places like Spain or Argentina? Does a nap really interfere with the ability to sleep at night like so many sleep centers caution? Not for Jane of Oakland. She reportedly took 5 hour naps as a baby, something many parents dream of but very few experience. Even when her mother would interrupt her daytime napping with the hope of getting her to bed earlier at night, Jane couldn’t go to sleep until 10pm. Indeed, at age 57, Jane still takes daytime naps in addition to her 8 hours of slumber at night! She goes to bed late (midnight) and rises at 8am. Naps do not interfere with her ability to sleep at night. She is what sleep researchers call an evening chronotype or “night owl.” Her family often jokes that she should live in Spain.
Daytime Naps: The Siesta
Think again, family. Latin Americans today may actually sleep less than we believe. Writer, Maya Kroth studied the concept of the “siesta” in Spain and discovered that very few Spaniards actually take a snooze during the day. Given the fact that they also work until 7 or 8pm in the evening, their dinnertime often occurs after 9pm and prime time television usually goes past midnight. Considering they often have to be at work in the morning as do we, this doesn’t allow them a whole lot of sleep time. Maya discovered that whether in Barcelona or in the southern, more rural area of Andalusia, napping was found in roughly 17% of Spaniards, with the Barcelonans clocking in at 17.1% and the Andalusians at 16.6%. (Kroth 2015.) Interestingly a 2009 Pew Research study found that nearly one third of Americans nap!
Spanish sleep doctor, Eduard Estivill, M. D., maintains that because body temperature normally warms up 6-8 hours after we wake up, that an afternoon nap is biologically prudent. In essence, the body asks for it. Furthermore, psychologist Sara Mednick, Ph.D found that naps improve memory and learning ability. Just as we are better able to perform perceptual learning tasks after a good night’s sleep, those that perform them shortly after a nap do better than those that don’t. The nap even seemed more potent than a caffeine fix when it came to subjects’ performance on a verbal word recall test (Mednick 2008.) There are many studies of this type with similar results (Cote 2009; Walker, M. 2011.)
Are We Designed to Nap?
Then you have Jerry Siegel’s hunter/gatherer population (see post from June 23rd.) These are people living today as our ancestors did long ago. They are nomads, living off the land and they don’t nap. They may relax in the shade and slow down a bit in the afternoon, but they don’t doze off, even though they only sleep between 6 and 7 hours a night. Because these groups exemplify how our ancestors probably slept, their habits may indicate that we are designed to not nap.
Back to Jane, who naps daily and doesn’t feel as sharp or emotionally calm if she doesn’t, the amount of time seems to be key as well as the individual. While Estivill recommends we take 20 minute naps or what some Americans refer to as “power naps,” Jane feels this is a drop in the bucket (remember she was a 5 hour napper baby.) As an adult she likes a solid hour! Many researchers argue that if we sleep longer than the 20 minute power nap, we move into deep sleep which can then start to disturb our nighttime sleep. Other researchers, such as Mednick, tout the benefits of a full sleep cycle nap of 90 minutes, stating these longer naps seem to positively affect learning in the same way getting a good night’s sleep can because they span an entire sleep cycle. In other words, longer naps can be quite restorative.
Daytime Naps: Conclusion
So the jury is still out on whether to nap or not. It is my experience that some patients, like Jane, are born nappers and truly benefit from this afternoon snooze. Others are not. A nap will keep them awake at night, interfering with their ability to get a good night’s sleep. Those with insomnia should take a good look at whether they are napping or not and determine whether their nighttime sleep improves without the nap. Do you recognize yourself in any of these conditions? If you simply don’t get enough sleep at night or are tired during the day, experiment with short naps of 20 minutes to see if these breaks restore your energy but don’t rob you of nighttime slumber. That’s what many companies, such as Google, are doing today…providing their employees with the space and time to take naps. Their hope? A more creative and productive workforce. Jane would approve.
Dr. Van Deusen received her PhD in Clinical Psychology from the California School of Professional Psychology in Los Angeles in 1992. She has cultivated deep knowledge of attachment theory and stress and has worked with various populations over her two and a half decade career. Her practice is in Seattle, Washington. Buy her book Stressed in the U.S.: 12 Tools to Tackle Anxiety, Loneliness, Tech-Addiction and More here
I would have to agree with Jane. My body tells me when I really need a nap and I always feel so much better when I listen.
I am 94 years old and while I don’t take a nap everyday, when I do, I sleep for an hour and a half to two hours. The naps seem to help me stay up to watch the 10 o’clock news, but they do not disrupt my sleep at night.